|
>>
|
No. 2356
1. Rorschach was obviously a homophobe, a hater of communists, an indoctrinated nationalist, and hanging off the faaaar edge of right wing extremist thought. Anyone who thinks otherwise needs to read the words rather than just look at the pretty pictures.
2. Rorschach's political and moral views should have no bearing whatsoever when it comes down to whose side you would have taken at the end of the story. It's not a popularity contest about who you like more. It's an all-or-nothing decision with the lives of millions in the balance either way. I'm about as far left as you can get politically, but saying Rorschach's choice in this instance was wrong because "he's a republican lol" is fucking retarded.
3. The main difference between the nuking of Japan and the *******ing of New York, in my mind, was what went on behind the scenes. With Hiroshima and Nagasaki, we knew who dropped the bombs, we knew where they dropped them, and we knew why. We didn't hide it or pretend it was anything that it wasn't. Ozy, however, would publicly accept no responsibility for what he did. It was carried out in secret and the truth of the matter would never be known. It's not the deaths of so many that get Rorschach riled, I don't think, but the immorality of Ozy's duplicity and scheming.
If nothing else, Rorschach hated communists and gays because he felt their being such was a crime, or at least an affront to deceny (whether or not we would agree). Ozy knew he would be killing at least some people who were wholly innocent, allegedly for the greater good. Rorschach was hateful, prejudiced, and narrow-minded, but he lived only to pass judgement on evildoers, not sacrifice some innocents for the good of more innocents.
|